vs

Simple Analytics vs Umami: Which is Better in 2026?

Analytics

Simple Analytics and Umami are both Analytics tools, made for different people. Simple Analytics is for site owners who want a cookie-free traffic dashboard, with a free plan for hobby sites. Umami is for developers who want open-source, cookie-free analytics they can self-host on Postgres or buy hosted.

Quick verdict

There’s no single winner; pick on your constraint. Choose Simple Analytics if you want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge. Choose Umami if you want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.

Simple Analytics vs Umami: Side by Side

Simple AnalyticsUmami
CategoryAnalyticsAnalytics
What it isPrivacy-friendly web analyticsOpen-source web analytics
What it measuresWebsite trafficWebsite traffic and events
Self-hostingNo (hosted)Yes (MIT, PostgreSQL)
How you payMonthly plan by pageviews, plus per extra userFree, or monthly plan plus per-event overage
Free access5 sites, 1 month of data, badge required100,000 events a month (Hobby)
PricingFree · paid from $20/moFree · paid from $20/mo
Starting priceFree tier availableFree tier available
Free tier
Rating4.04.1
Best forAnalytics: cookie-free, EU data, free hobby planAnalytics: open source, self-hosted, free tier

Ratings are App Stack Builder’s editorial score out of 5, not an average of user reviews.

Pros & Cons

  • One-page dashboard
  • No personal data collected
  • Free plan for hobby sites
  • Limited depth for product analysis
  • Free plan keeps 1 month of data
  • Extra users cost $20 a month each
  • MIT licensed and self-hostable
  • Free tier covers 100k monthly events
  • Usage overage instead of forced upgrades
  • Self-hosting means running a database
  • Fewer advanced reports

Key Features Compared

Simple Analytics

  • Free for hobby sites: 5 websites, 1 user, 1 month of data, badge required
  • Self-serve from $20 a month for 100,000 pageviews; $20 a month per extra user
  • Yearly billing gives 2 months free
  • 14-day free trial, no credit card
  • AI assistant available; data leaves the EU only if you opt in to such features
  • Enterprise: custom pricing with a 30-day proof of concept

Umami

  • Hobby (free cloud): 100,000 events a month, 1 website, 6 months of data
  • Pro $20 a month: 1M events, up to 20 websites, up to 10 team members, 2 years of data
  • Pro overage: $0.00003 per extra event
  • Business $200 a month: 10M events, unlimited websites and members, 5 years of data
  • Open source under the MIT license; self-hosting needs PostgreSQL v12.14+
  • Cloud adds email reports and a streaming API that self-hosting lacks

Choose Simple Analytics if…

  • You want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge.
  • You want analytics data kept in the EU by default.
  • You want a trial without entering a card.

Choose Umami if…

  • You want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.
  • You want a free hosted plan for one site.
  • You want usage-based overage rather than jumping to a bigger plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Simple Analytics better than Umami?⌄

There’s no single winner; pick on your constraint. Choose Simple Analytics if you want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge. Choose Umami if you want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.

What is the difference between Simple Analytics and Umami?⌄

What it is. Simple Analytics: Privacy-friendly web analytics. Umami: Open-source web analytics. What it measures. Simple Analytics: Website traffic. Umami: Website traffic and events. Self-hosting. Simple Analytics: No (hosted). Umami: Yes (MIT, PostgreSQL). How you pay. Simple Analytics: Monthly plan by pageviews, plus per extra user. Umami: Free, or monthly plan plus per-event overage. Free access. Simple Analytics: 5 sites, 1 month of data, badge required. Umami: 100,000 events a month (Hobby).

Simple Analytics vs Umami: which is cheaper?⌄

Simple Analytics pricing: Free · paid from $20/mo. Umami pricing: Free · paid from $20/mo. Confirm current pricing on each tool's official site, as plans change.

Which is rated higher, Simple Analytics or Umami?⌄

On our editorial score, Simple Analytics is 4.0 out of 5 and Umami is 4.1 out of 5, so Umami is slightly ahead. This is our own score, not an average of user reviews.

When should I skip both Simple Analytics and Umami?⌄

Skip Simple Analytics if you need more than a month of history for free. Umami Hobby keeps 6 months. Skip Umami if you want funnels and ecommerce revenue on an entry plan. Plausible Business includes both.

Sources · tool facts checked November 2026

  1. 1.Simple Analytics pricingsimpleanalytics.com
  2. 2.Umami pricingumami.is
  3. 3.Umami on GitHubgithub.com

See more options in our guide to the best analytics tools for startups.

Still not sure which to pick?

Get a free, AI-powered tech stack, including the best analytics pick for your budget and team, in 60 seconds.

Build my stack free