Simple Analytics vs Umami: Which is Better in 2026?
Simple Analytics and Umami are both Analytics tools, made for different people. Simple Analytics is for site owners who want a cookie-free traffic dashboard, with a free plan for hobby sites. Umami is for developers who want open-source, cookie-free analytics they can self-host on Postgres or buy hosted.
Quick verdict
There’s no single winner; pick on your constraint. Choose Simple Analytics if you want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge. Choose Umami if you want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.
Simple Analytics vs Umami: Side by Side
| Simple Analytics | Umami | |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Analytics | Analytics |
| What it is | Privacy-friendly web analytics | Open-source web analytics |
| What it measures | Website traffic | Website traffic and events |
| Self-hosting | No (hosted) | Yes (MIT, PostgreSQL) |
| How you pay | Monthly plan by pageviews, plus per extra user | Free, or monthly plan plus per-event overage |
| Free access | 5 sites, 1 month of data, badge required | 100,000 events a month (Hobby) |
| Pricing | Free · paid from $20/mo | Free · paid from $20/mo |
| Starting price | Free tier available | Free tier available |
| Free tier | ||
| Rating | 4.0 | 4.1 |
| Best for | Analytics: cookie-free, EU data, free hobby plan | Analytics: open source, self-hosted, free tier |
Ratings are App Stack Builder’s editorial score out of 5, not an average of user reviews.
Pros & Cons
- One-page dashboard
- No personal data collected
- Free plan for hobby sites
- Limited depth for product analysis
- Free plan keeps 1 month of data
- Extra users cost $20 a month each
- MIT licensed and self-hostable
- Free tier covers 100k monthly events
- Usage overage instead of forced upgrades
- Self-hosting means running a database
- Fewer advanced reports
Key Features Compared
Simple Analytics
- Free for hobby sites: 5 websites, 1 user, 1 month of data, badge required
- Self-serve from $20 a month for 100,000 pageviews; $20 a month per extra user
- Yearly billing gives 2 months free
- 14-day free trial, no credit card
- AI assistant available; data leaves the EU only if you opt in to such features
- Enterprise: custom pricing with a 30-day proof of concept
Umami
- Hobby (free cloud): 100,000 events a month, 1 website, 6 months of data
- Pro $20 a month: 1M events, up to 20 websites, up to 10 team members, 2 years of data
- Pro overage: $0.00003 per extra event
- Business $200 a month: 10M events, unlimited websites and members, 5 years of data
- Open source under the MIT license; self-hosting needs PostgreSQL v12.14+
- Cloud adds email reports and a streaming API that self-hosting lacks
Choose Simple Analytics if…
- You want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge.
- You want analytics data kept in the EU by default.
- You want a trial without entering a card.
Choose Umami if…
- You want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.
- You want a free hosted plan for one site.
- You want usage-based overage rather than jumping to a bigger plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Simple Analytics better than Umami?⌄
There’s no single winner; pick on your constraint. Choose Simple Analytics if you want a free plan for small sites and can show a badge. Choose Umami if you want to self-host free, MIT-licensed analytics on Postgres.
What is the difference between Simple Analytics and Umami?⌄
What it is. Simple Analytics: Privacy-friendly web analytics. Umami: Open-source web analytics. What it measures. Simple Analytics: Website traffic. Umami: Website traffic and events. Self-hosting. Simple Analytics: No (hosted). Umami: Yes (MIT, PostgreSQL). How you pay. Simple Analytics: Monthly plan by pageviews, plus per extra user. Umami: Free, or monthly plan plus per-event overage. Free access. Simple Analytics: 5 sites, 1 month of data, badge required. Umami: 100,000 events a month (Hobby).
Simple Analytics vs Umami: which is cheaper?⌄
Simple Analytics pricing: Free · paid from $20/mo. Umami pricing: Free · paid from $20/mo. Confirm current pricing on each tool's official site, as plans change.
Which is rated higher, Simple Analytics or Umami?⌄
On our editorial score, Simple Analytics is 4.0 out of 5 and Umami is 4.1 out of 5, so Umami is slightly ahead. This is our own score, not an average of user reviews.
When should I skip both Simple Analytics and Umami?⌄
Skip Simple Analytics if you need more than a month of history for free. Umami Hobby keeps 6 months. Skip Umami if you want funnels and ecommerce revenue on an entry plan. Plausible Business includes both.
Sources · tool facts checked November 2026
See more options in our guide to the best analytics tools for startups.
Still not sure which to pick?
Get a free, AI-powered tech stack, including the best analytics pick for your budget and team, in 60 seconds.